Hunger Games prequel splits opinion: ‘Surreally awful’ or ‘surprisingly strong’

Image source, Lionsgate

Image caption, Joseph Zada plays Haymitch Abernathy at the age of 16

ByIan Youngs

Culture reporter

Reviews of the latest Hunger Games film have seen it dismissed as a “surreally awful prequel” and “a tortuous, costly mess” by some critics – but called “surprisingly strong” and “one of the best films in the series” by others.

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is the sixth movie in the franchise, and tells the origin story of a teenage Haymitch Abernathy – who was played as an adult by Woody Harrelson.

In a one-star review, the Guardian called the film, external “overwrought and boring”, and said it “has no actual interest and no authentic reason to exist, other than to gouge an income stream out of its fanbase”.

But the Wrap praised its, external “memorable performances, intoxicating style and horrifying commentary”, adding: “When the dust settles it may even be the Hunger Games that holds up best.”

Image source, Murray Close/Lionsgate

Image caption, Ralph Fiennes stars as President Snow

Sunrise on the Reaping is set 24 years before the first Hunger Games film, and 40 years after the previous prequel, 2023’s The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes.

“This prequel lands at some mid-point between Ballad and Hunger Games, which puts it on an immediately odd footing,” Empire said in a three-star review, external.

“It can’t escape the sense of feeling supplementary. It’s an enjoyable-enough diversion, but essentially a footnote with aspirations.”

Screen Daily called it, external an “underwhelming prequel”, which “suffers from a lack of compelling characters” and “feels oddly incidental – a drab afterthought rather than a crucial new chapter”.

Image source, Murray Close/Lionsgate

Image caption, Kieran Culkin plays Hunger Games host Caesar Flickerman

The film’s all-star cast includes Ralph Fiennes, Jesse Plemons, Glenn Close, Kieran Culkin, Elle Fanning, Mckenna Grace and Maya Hawke alongside Joseph Zada as the 16-year-old Abernathy.

IndieWire, external said Zada’s performance is “charming enough”, but “his character lacks the gravitational charisma or arc that, say, Jennifer Lawrence brought to the original films”.

The movie feels “a little bit like a cold cash grab rather than a necessary deepening of the series’ lore” and is “a dreary slog”, IndieWire’s critic wrote.

The New York Times, external also used the word “slog”, adding: “One really misses the guiding presence of Jennifer Lawrence, who had the raw pathos to both ground and expand a world in a way many younger stars often can’t.

“In Sunrise, we’re instead left with fleeting moments in which Plemons or Ralph Fiennes (playing the evil President Snow) briefly elevate the film. They seem to be trapped in this dystopia too.”

Image source, Murray Close/Lionsgate

Image caption, The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping will be released this weekend

However, the Hollywood Reporter, external was more enthusiastic about both the film and Zada’s performance, calling it a “star-making turn”.

Its critic concluded: “Sunrise on the Reaping is a return, after the disappointing Songbirds and Snakes, to the spirit of the first movies.”

And Time Out’s four-star review, external said the film is “as strong as any” of the other movies, and “certainly a major step up from 2023’s drab prequel The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes”.

Related topics

Hot this week

Philippines police ask prosecutors to charge Thomas Markle over child sex abuse material

Police in the Philippines have asked prosecutors to charge...

Democrat Mary Peltola unseats Republican in Alaska Senate race

Democrat Mary Peltola has won Alaska's hard-fought Senate race,...

Rubio says tech outages are not part of ‘systemic attack’ against US

US Secretary of State Marco Rubio has dismissed widespread...

Higher fuel prices push UK inflation to 3.6%

Higher petrol and diesel prices pushed the UK's inflation...

Topics

Democrat Mary Peltola unseats Republican in Alaska Senate race

Democrat Mary Peltola has won Alaska's hard-fought Senate race,...

Rubio says tech outages are not part of ‘systemic attack’ against US

US Secretary of State Marco Rubio has dismissed widespread...

Higher fuel prices push UK inflation to 3.6%

Higher petrol and diesel prices pushed the UK's inflation...

American soldier arrested in UK taken into US military custody

American soldier arrested by UK police on suspicion of...

Guernsey States to debate 0.5% social security contributions cut

"Social security contributions have been increased each year as...

How important are Nvidia and Jensen Huang to the US economy?

Nvidia and its co-founder Jensen Huang have been at...

Related Articles

Popular Categories