Steven McIntoshEntertainment reporter
Watch: Tim Davie told BBC Breakfast the BBC was seen globally as a ‘glowing light’ of independent broadcasting
The BBC director general has said viewers are worried about political interference in the corporation, following the results of a major questionnaire about the broadcaster.
More than 870,000 members of the public answered questions online about the BBC and its place in society.
Fewer than half – 43% – said they thought the corporation was effective at being independent from government, while 38% thought it was ineffective.
“Yes, that is what people worry about,” Mr Davie told BBC Breakfast. “They worry about, is the BBC being unduly influenced?”
Of the respondents, 91% said it was important for the BBC to be independent from the government of the day.
Mr Davie said the BBC is “absolutely not” unduly influenced by the government, and that the corporation’s independence is “absolutely sacrosanct”.
“I can reassure everyone we are independent editorially. We absolutely act without fear or favour,” he said.
Asked about instances when government ministers call him to complain about the BBC’s output, he said: “Very, very rarely will somebody call me on an editorial issue, because broadly speaking, it is respected that we have editorial independence.”
The BBC is perceived globally as being a model of independent broadcasting, he noted.
The BBC invited audience members to have their say in a series of on-air promotions across TV and radio. It also sent emails to 40 million BBC account holders.
The results of the Our BBC, Our Future questionnaire come after the relationship between the BBC and the government has been in the spotlight.
Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy appeared to call for Mr Davie’s resignation this summer after a string of scandals, including antisemitic comments by punk duo Bob Vylan at Glastonbury being broadcast on iPlayer, and the revelation that a Gaza documentary was narrated by the son of a Hamas official.
In August, former BBC director of news James Harding told the Edinburgh TV Festival that Nandy’s involvement in the Bob Vylan scandal was “chilling”, and criticised “political interference”, or the perception of it, at the BBC.
Last year, BBC chair Samir Shah said there was “an almost perpetual government review over the BBC” as a result of the requirement for ministers to renew the broadcaster’s royal charter every 10 years.
Meanwhile, questions about the BBC’s independence were raised when former Tory donor and Rishi Sunak’s ex-boss Richard Sharp was named BBC chair in 2021. Mr Sharp resigned two years later over his links to Boris Johnson.
Also in 2021, Theresa May’s former communications chief Sir Robbie Gibb was appointed to the BBC board.
Asked if he listens to any concerns raised with him, Mr Davie replied: “We listen to it, but we’re not reacting to one lobby or the other.
“What we’re trying to do is, if someone raises a valid point or a factual inaccuracy, we can check that. So I think the idea that the BBC’s not listening or we wouldn’t take a call is ridiculous.”
He added: “If you talk to any of our leaders in the newsroom, our orders are very clear – report against the editorial guidelines, without fear or favour.
“People will call and say things, but I don’t think we’re influenced by that. What we’re influenced by is our standards, our editorial guidelines.”
He concluded: “It’s not an invalid concern to be worried about governmental interference in broadcasting and free journalism. I would say the BBC is a glowing light on that, and that is what we need to fight for, and it is a worry.”
One other major gap identified by the questionnaire results was the percentage of respondents who felt the BBC should reflect different parts of the UK and the people who live there (76%), and the percentage who felt it actually did (51%).
“These are gaps that will need to be worked on and addressed as a priority as the BBC’s future is debated and we plan how to serve the public better,” the BBC said.
The questionnaire also found:
80% of respondents said it was important for the corporation to offer high-quality digital services, while 78% said the BBC should offer something for everyone82% said it was important to provide a valuable public service, while 76% said it should be an asset for the UK around the world83% said it was important that the BBC continued its mission to inform, educate and entertainIn a statement released with the questionnaire results, Mr Davie described the response to the questionnaire as “incredible”, which he said “shows just how much people care about the BBC”.
“I strongly believe the BBC has never been more needed, both in the UK and around the world,” he said.
“The results of the questionnaire are clear – our audience wants an independent BBC, delivering high-quality programmes and content that they can trust; that tells the stories that matter to them and that reflect their lives.”
Mr Davie thanked those who took part, adding: “We are here to deliver for audiences across the UK and we will be taking everything they have told us with us as we shape the future of the BBC.”
