‘A profound ‌restriction on political debate’: Reddit blasts Australia’s social media ban, but the government says it is defending the law against ‘sustained ideological attack’

The Reddit logo is being displayed on a smartphone with the Reddit logo also visible in the background
(Image credit: Getty / NurPhoto)

  • Reddit wants to overturn Australia’s social media ban for under-16s
  • It is challenging the law in the Australian High Court
  • Government says it’s defending the law from “sustained ideological attack”

In late 2025, Australia became the first nation in the world to ban social media for under-16s — and as you would expect, that hasn’t gone down particularly well with the app makers affected. Reddit, for example, has issued a stinging rebuke to the Australian government and is in the process of challenging the ban in court.

A lawyer representing Reddit called the ban “ill thought out” (via Reuters) and said it was a “profound ‌restriction on political debate.” The attorney was speaking at the Australian High Court, where Reddit is seeking to contest the country’s new law.

Together with a libertarian advocacy group, Reddit claimed in court that the social media ban was “a very substantial restriction on what young people can now do” and that it could stifle political debate. It added that the restrictions may stop users creating content and responding to posts.

Although Reddit said it supported the aims of the law, it branded the legislation “inept,” saying that it did not have any specific means to keep minors off social media and failed to regulate other platforms where cyberbullying might take place, such as on gaming websites. And the fact that users who were not logged in could still view huge amounts of material undermined the law, Reddit argued.

Could Reddit overturn the ban?

A child holding an iPhone in their hands

(Image credit: Getty Images / Anna Barclay)

Since the Australian law came into effect, several studies have shown that large numbers of teenage users targeted by it are still able to access restricted material. Sometimes, that might be as simple as using a VPN service to disguise your location, while at other times, social media firms are simply not taking action to restrict usage by under-16s.

Despite Reddit’s criticism, the Australian government has said it will defend its legislation. In court, the state’s lawyer, Joanna Davidson, said that children were more vulnerable to harmful online content because their brains were not fully developed compared to those of adults.

And speaking outside the High Court, communications ⁠minister Anika Wells ​said: “We ​are here to defend a fundamental tenet of Australian democracy, which is an Australian’s right, and particularly an Australian child’s right, to be free from harm. We seek ​to defend that from sustained ideological attack.”

Sign up for breaking news, reviews, opinion, top tech deals, and more.

The government has doubled the maximum fine for non-compliance with the law to AU$99 million (about $69.5 million / £51.5 million), increased the discovery powers of the eSafety Commissioner, and said it is preparing enforcement action against some of the largest social media platforms operating in Australia.

Whatever side you take on this matter, it’s clear that neither the Australian government nor Reddit are preparing to back down anytime soon. And with other nations considering similar laws, many people around the world will be watching closely.


Google logo on a black background next to text reading 'Click to follow TechRadar'

Follow TechRadar on Google News and add us as a preferred source to get our expert news, reviews, and opinion in your feeds.


An Apple MacBook Air against a white background

Alex Blake has been fooling around with computers since the early 1990s, and since that time he’s learned a thing or two about tech. No more than two things, though. That’s all his brain can hold. As well as TechRadar, Alex writes for iMore, Digital Trends and Creative Bloq, among others. He was previously commissioning editor at MacFormat magazine. That means he mostly covers the world of Apple and its latest products, but also Windows, computer peripherals, mobile apps, and much more beyond. When not writing, you can find him hiking the English countryside and gaming on his PC.

Hot this week

Rubio urges Venezuela to release remaining political prisoners

The US has urged Venezuela to release the remaining...

Indian tourist killed after helicopters collide near Everest base camp

An Indian tourist has died after two helicopters collided...

US strikes Iranian island ahead of midterm elections

The US has carried out strikes on Iran's Qeshm...

Agoa: Donald Trump to remove Rwanda and South Africa from US trade deal

US President Donald Trump has notified Congress of his...

Florida plane crash investigators say jet may have broken apart before impact as family named

Investigators believe parts of a private jet which crashed...

Topics

Rubio urges Venezuela to release remaining political prisoners

The US has urged Venezuela to release the remaining...

Indian tourist killed after helicopters collide near Everest base camp

An Indian tourist has died after two helicopters collided...

US strikes Iranian island ahead of midterm elections

The US has carried out strikes on Iran's Qeshm...

Agoa: Donald Trump to remove Rwanda and South Africa from US trade deal

US President Donald Trump has notified Congress of his...

Car finance: Compensation payments explained

Image source, Getty Images ByKevin Peachey Cost of living correspondent Millions of...

Jesus de Miguel: Tenerife striker dies after on-field collision

Tenerife striker Jesus de Miguel has died after the...

Related Articles

Popular Categories